New and young drivers pay substantially higher car insurance premiums than experienced drivers in Australia. This is not arbitrary — it reflects claims data. Drivers under 25 are involved in a disproportionate share of at-fault accidents, and drivers in their first 1–3 years of licence holding have higher claim frequency than more experienced drivers regardless of age. Insurers price this risk accordingly.
Understanding the factors that drive the premium — and which of them you can actually influence — is more useful than simply shopping for the cheapest quote.
| Factor | Your control | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Driver age (under 25) | None — time-based | High — typically the largest single factor |
| Years of experience | None — accumulates with time | High — directly correlated with claims frequency |
| Vehicle value and type | Yes — choose a lower-value, lower-risk vehicle | Moderate to high |
| Vehicle storage (garage vs street) | Yes — if you can garage your car | Moderate |
| Annual kilometres driven | Yes — declare honestly, lower if accurate | Moderate |
| Excess level | Yes — choosing higher excess reduces premium | Moderate |
| Cover type (comprehensive vs TPPD) | Yes | Significant — TPPD is substantially cheaper |
Most comprehensive policies apply an additional "young driver excess" or "inexperienced driver excess" on top of the standard policy excess when a driver under 25 or with fewer than 2–3 years of licence experience is driving at the time of an accident. This excess is applied per claim, in addition to your standard excess.
A typical young driver excess is $400–$800, though some policies go higher. If your standard excess is $700 and the young driver excess is $600, a small at-fault claim that costs $1,800 to repair may net you only $500 after excesses — effectively making the insurance near-useless for low-value incidents.
Always check the young driver excess before purchasing a policy. It should be clearly stated in the Product Disclosure Statement under the excess section. Add the young driver excess to the standard excess to understand your total out-of-pocket cost on any claim.
For a new driver with an older, lower-value car — say, a vehicle worth $8,000–$12,000 — comprehensive insurance may not be cost-effective. If the annual premium is $2,000 and the excess on any claim is $1,300 combined, the insurance only pays out meaningfully on claims above $3,300. For a car worth $10,000, you might decide the cost of comprehensive isn't worth it.
Third party property damage (TPPD) — which covers damage you cause to other people's vehicles and property — is substantially cheaper and addresses the financially catastrophic risk: causing $80,000 of damage to someone's car or property. Your own car is not covered, but the liability to others is. For a new driver on a tight budget with a modest car, TPPD is often the more rational choice.
If a parent or household member holds the policy and the young driver is listed as a named driver, the premium may be lower than if the young driver holds the policy themselves — because the policy is rated on the primary driver. However, declaring the wrong primary driver is "fronting," which is insurance fraud and will void the policy at claim time.
If a young driver is the primary user of a vehicle, they must be listed as the primary driver. They can still benefit from sharing the policy with an older driver if that older driver genuinely uses the car as well — but the primary driver designation must be accurate.
The fastest way to reduce insurance costs as a new driver is to accumulate years of claims-free driving. Most insurers apply a no-claims discount (NCD) or rating system that reduces premiums for each consecutive year without a claim. Protecting your NCD by not claiming for minor incidents you can afford to pay out of pocket becomes strategically worthwhile once you have built some history.
Check whether your car insurance is priced at the current market rate for your profile.
Check My Car Insurance