Insurance companies charge existing customers more than they charge new ones. This is not speculation — it is a documented commercial practice in home, car, and health insurance across Australia. The ACCC's Northern Australian Insurance Inquiry and various state consumer affairs reviews have all noted that renewal premiums consistently exceed new customer pricing for comparable risk. The mechanism is simple: insurers know most customers will auto-renew without shopping around. If you do not push back at renewal, you fund that assumption.
The good news is that negotiating at renewal is straightforward, takes about 30 minutes, and works more often than most people expect. The key is having competing quotes before you call — and knowing exactly what to say.
Insurers justify renewal premium increases through a combination of: claims inflation (rebuild costs, car parts prices, medical costs), changes to your risk profile (property age, vehicle age, claims history), portfolio-level repricing, and — importantly — deliberate loyalty pricing. The last factor is real. ASIC's 2020 insurance pricing review found that some insurers specifically charged long-tenure customers higher premiums, relying on renewal inertia rather than risk-based factors to retain them. The practice has attracted regulatory attention but has not been eliminated.
Premium increases of 10–30% at renewal are common in the current environment. A 20% increase on a $2,000 home insurance policy is $400 a year. That is worth 30 minutes of your time.
Get your renewal notice. Note the exact premium, excess, coverage limits, and any changes from the prior year. Some insurers quietly change exclusions or reduce coverage while increasing the premium — read the renewal summary carefully, not just the dollar figure.
Get three competing quotes. Use the same coverage parameters as your renewal: same sum insured, same excess, same key features. Do not compare a $1,000 excess policy against your current $500 excess policy — that is not a real comparison. The quotes need to be genuinely comparable to be useful as leverage.
Call your insurer's retention line (not the general customer service number). Tell them you have received your renewal notice and you have found comparable cover for less with other insurers. Give them the best competing price. Ask whether they can match or beat it.
If they offer a reduction, ask whether that is their best price. Retention staff often have discretion to offer further reductions if pushed. If the first number they offer is $100 less, it is reasonable to ask once more whether they can do better.
If they cannot match the competing price and the competing insurer is reputable (check AFCA complaint volumes and product reviews), switch. The savings compound over multiple years — a $350 annual saving is $1,750 over five years.
Be direct and specific. The following works:
"I've just received my renewal notice for $[X]. I've done some comparisons and I can get the same coverage with [Insurer Name] for $[Y]. Can you match that, or do I need to switch when this policy expires?"
Do not apologise. Do not make it personal. Treat it as a commercial conversation. Retention staff understand exactly what is happening and will usually engage constructively. If the first person says they cannot reduce the premium, ask to speak to a senior retention specialist or team leader — they typically have more discretion.
Many insurers offer discounts that are not automatically applied at renewal. These include: multi-policy discount (holding home and car with the same insurer), annual payment discount (paying upfront rather than monthly, which carries an interest component), and online policy discount (managing your policy digitally). If you are not on any of these, ask about them in the same call. A multi-policy discount is typically 5–15% and stacks with a retention reduction.
Call two to three weeks before your renewal date, not on the day. This gives you time to follow up if the first call doesn't resolve it, and gives you time to action a switch without a gap in cover. Most insurers allow you to cancel within 30 days of renewal and receive a pro-rata refund if you have already paid, but avoiding that process is easier if you act ahead of time.
Health insurance is partially regulated differently — private health funds are required to apply the same premium to all members within the same product tier, so negotiating a lower rate within your current policy is generally not possible in the same way it is for general insurance. However, you can switch to a comparable product at another fund and not serve new waiting periods for conditions already covered. The switching mechanism is different: it is fund-to-fund portability rather than in-fund negotiation. The competitive shopping step (comparing products before renewal) is still valuable.
Every year at renewal. Set a calendar reminder two weeks before your renewal date for each policy. The market changes annually, new entrants price aggressively for customer acquisition, and your existing insurer's pricing may shift. Treating renewal as automatic is the behaviour insurers are pricing to exploit.
Find out if you're overpaying on your current insurance and see what comparable cover costs.
Check My Insurance